Trader Joe’s candy aisle has built a cult following, and chocolate is where the fans get the loudest. To help you on your next trip, we’ve compiled a list of the most sought-after chocolate finds that shoppers keep coming back for.
01
of 10
Made with real peanut butter from slowly roasted Virginia peanuts and wrapped in rich, high quality dark chocolate, this is one of Trader Joe’s longest running fan favorites. It skips the artificial flavors and extra fillers other brands rely on. Shoppers regularly rank it above national candy brands for its balance of chocolate and peanut butter.
02
of 10
Each cluster layers a chewy caramel-cookie-brownie base, then gets enrobed in melted dark chocolate, drizzled with more chocolate, and finished with a light sprinkle of sea salt. It combines three dessert textures, chewy caramel, crumbly cookie, and fudgy brownie, into a single bite sized candy. The sea salt finish keeps the richness balanced instead of one note sweet.
One of the standout new releases, this Belgium made bar mixes whole almonds, sea salt, and crunchy honey nuggets into smooth milk chocolate. Almonds make up roughly 15 percent of the recipe, giving it a satisfying crunch in every bite. Food bloggers have compared its flavor and texture to a cross between Tony’s Chocolonely and Toblerone.
04
of 10
A lightly salted, vanilla tinged caramel square gets coated in full flavored dark chocolate for a treat that plays sweet against bitter. The bitter notes in the chocolate bring out the vanilla in the caramel, while the caramel softens the chocolate’s fruitier edges. It is a simple two ingredient combination that regularly sells out around the holidays.
05
of 10
This mix bundles sea salt potato chips, corn chip dippers, and mini pretzel nuggets, then coats the whole assortment in milk chocolate. It plays on the classic sweet and salty combination but delivers it as one grab and go snack instead of separate chips and chocolate. The variety of textures, crispy, crunchy, and smooth, keeps shoppers reaching back into the bag.
Dry roasted, California grown almonds get finished by hand in small batches, with half dipped in milk chocolate and half in dark chocolate. The mix of textures, crunchy almonds against smooth chocolate, keeps this bag in steady rotation on shopping lists. Many customers grab one of each type for the contrast in flavor.
Part of Trader Joe’s oversized Pound Plus lineup, this bar layers creamy Belgian milk chocolate with rich caramel, crunchy pretzel bits, and flaky sea salt. Its large format makes it popular for sharing, snapping into pieces, or breaking up for baking projects. The salty and sweet combination keeps it a repeat purchase for regulars.
Made by an expert supplier in Madagascar using cocoa and vanilla sourced exclusively from the region, this bar has a complex, bittersweet flavor with floral, spiced notes from the vanilla bean. It stands out from Trader Joe’s other dark chocolate bars for its single origin sourcing, a detail chocolate enthusiasts tend to seek out. Shoppers often pair it with coffee, tea, or a glass of red wine for a more elevated tasting experience.
This bark spreads a thick slab of dark chocolate with whole almonds, pretzel pieces, and sea salt for a treat with crunch in nearly every bite. It breaks apart easily into shareable, uneven pieces, which fans say makes it feel more like a homemade candy than a packaged one. The combination of nutty, salty, and sweet keeps it high on repeat purchase lists.
For shoppers who want the crunch of a chocolate covered almond without a heavy shell, this snack uses a lighter dusting of dark chocolate over each nut. The thinner coating lets the roasted almond flavor come through more than a traditional chocolate covered almond. It has become a favorite for anyone snacking with moderation in mind, minus the guilt of a fully coated treat.